law ofc car law firm kasra sadr. SADR LAW OFFICE, A PROFESSIONAL LAW CORPORATION is a California Stock Corporation - Ca - Professional filed on July 21, 2023. law ofc car law firm kasra sadr

 
 SADR LAW OFFICE, A PROFESSIONAL LAW CORPORATION is a California Stock Corporation - Ca - Professional filed on July 21, 2023law ofc car law firm kasra sadr  dba Hawthorne Motors Express (Plaintiff) filed suit against Kasra Sadr, Esq, the Sadr Law Firm, and the Car Law Firm, alleging: (1) defamation per se; (2) defamation per quod; (3) trade libel; (4) violation of

Closed 10/28/2016. District Court of the Eastern District of California in Sacramento, California with Case Number 2:20-CV-01034-MCE-AC (“Lawsuit”). Fax: 415-421-2830. Rubenstein & Rynecki and its predecessor have been representing victims of personal injury since 1972. , promise to deliver the highest level of advocacy and support possible to you and your family as you deal with serious and pressing legal challenges arising from an accident caused by someone. Button, Diana Akkawi and Yasmin Akkawi. 2 million settlement with Sephora USA, Inc. ECF No. (Hearing set for 8/20/2020 at 02:00 PM in Courtroom 7 (MCE) before Senior Judge Morrison C. Zero of the companies are still active while the remaining three are now listed as inactive. Established in 1993, Lord Heinlein is a partnership law firm in Minneapolis led by lawyers Priscilla Lord and Melissa Heinlein. CLF seeks toKasra Sadr/ The Car Law Firm files fictious and fradulent law suits which target auto dealers. San Diego, CA, 92108. is the Director of Global Operations at the Law Offices of Marjan Kasra, LLC. In California, Kasra Sadr, Esq. We have the necessary expertise, the requisite associations, and the large. Jones , P. After establishing one of California’s best consumer protection law firms, he has now established and is the co-founder and CEO of DrYnks. com. Similar Issues in Dallas: Personal Injury. A big law firm does not guarantee big results either. The presentation was awesome. 38. We take on tough cases through litigation and trial. Disposition. 1. ECF No. Today and We’ll Come To You! The days, weeks and even months following a personal injury incident can be extremely confusing and stressful, leaving many accident victims with more questions than answers: Do I have a case?As laws of the road vary from state to state, obtaining knowledge of local roads and laws can help position your case and understand which laws might apply. com Attorneysfor Plaintiffs, Kasra Sadr, Sadr Law Firm, APLC dba Car Law Firm and dba Sadr and Barrera Law Office [x] BY MAIL - by placing [x] a true and correct copy. Ad. JUDGMENT OF DISMISSAL in Criminal Case as to Kasra Sadr (3), Count(s) 1, 10-23, 2-4, 6-9, Indictment Dismissed without Prejudice. This is the right place for a quick learner professional able to think quickly and to adapt to the ever-changing landscape of US Immigration Laws. 1 at 2. AAA Case #011500041603, involving Sterling Imports, Ltd. Kasra Sadr was quite impressive while representing my case. Phone Number (619) 233-8460 Call Now! Company Website. Docket Entries. Jacksonville, FL. ECF Nos. com. in Biology and Psychology in 1991 from University of. San Francisco, CA 94105. The California Attorney General appears to be taking an aggressive approach to enforcing the CCPA, particularly relating to failures to implement and process global privacy control opt-out protocols. The company offers professional license defense and personal injury law, which includes car accidents. , Ste. 4. I watched him handle a top rated defense attorney without a worry or doubt as to winning my case. 415-538-2000. See more. No. AnyLaw is the FREE and Friendly legal research service that gives you unlimited access to massive amounts of valuable legal data. Unconfirmed. Find 5 listings related to Sadr And Barrera Law Office in Chula Vista on YP. United States. The Law Office of Amir Sadr. San Antonio, TX. Cyriacks is also referred to in the record as Cyriacks-Vella. The Car Law Firm, with attorney Kasra Sadr, is just one of hundreds of consumer lawyers who sue. 415-538-2000. Our client reviews, multiple contact options, and detailed profiles make it easy to find the Car Accident firm you need. review. Filed 12/30/2015. 2. CA 92122. Kasra Sadr has 20 years of experience as a lawyer since graduating from California Western School of. Super Lawyers ®. review. Produkte + Exposé schalten. 06-O-13226: 11/15/2002: Admitted to the State Bar of California. Once you create your profile, you will be able to:VS KASRA SADR, ESQ. Sadr & Barrera, APLC (S & B) is a law firm whose principals include attorney Kasra Sadr. ECF No. On 07/14/2010 The SADR Law Firm APLC filed a Contract - Other Contract lawsuit against Todd Alan Rodriguez. Attorney Kasra obtained her Juris Doctor Degree in 1999 from Quinnipiac University School of Law; Prior to attending Law School, she completed a rigorous curriculum in Science and Liberal Arts; she earned her B. Kasra Sadr, San Diego Reviews and Ratings,Tax, Business, Estate PlanningAttorney, San Diego County. PlainSite's data analytics profile for attorney Kasra Sadr. She was patient, informative, and communicative throughout our process. Signed by Magistrate Judge Paul M. 130 at 3. Reviewed By. 4850 Old Pineville Rd. 1455 Frazee Rd Ste 500. Refers to: Does 1 through 50 Filed By: Sadr, Kasra (Plaintiff); Sadr Law Firm APLC (Plaintiff); Sadr and Barrera Law Office (Plaintiff) [+] Read More [-]. Checkout Keyword Suggestion with other keyword: Show result. KASRA SADR, an individual; CAR LAW FIRM, a business entity form unknown; THE SADR LAW FIRM, a professional law corporation; NATIONWIDE VIN MARKETING, a business entity form unknown; CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF MOTOR VEHICLES, an agency of the State of California; and DOES 1 through 20, inclusive, Defendants. Car Accident Lawyers Serving Jacksonville, FL (Ocala) 6. We would highly recommend her to anyone looking for an immigration attorney!"Car Law Firm is an association between independent law firms and attorneys all across California and Texas, and focuses solely on dealer fraudulent activities. reviews. Fox; and Edmond Tarverdian seek to recover damages and obtain injunctive relief against Kasra Sadr (“Defendant Sadr”), the Car Law Firm (“Defendant CLF”), the. 20220928a31Attorney Search. We offer specific relief to all consumers who have been defrauded by false and misleading (and illegal) behaviour. The Kansas City personal injury lawyers at Brown & Crouppen can help you maximize your financial recovery. Car Accident Lawyers Serving Minneapolis, MN (Minneapolis, MN) 2. Learn about the lawyers that are suing car dealers in California over vehicle history and condition. heydari@carlawfirm. 1455 Frazee Road # 500 San Diego, CA 92108. C. When PlainSite users search for attorneys, make sure you show up near the top. , 20STCV29268 in California State, Los Angeles County, Superior Court, Jon R. We have the necessary expertise, the requisite associations, and the large. Ad. , Ste. ECF No. KASRA SADR, an individual; CAR LAW FIRM, a business entity form unknown; THE SADR LAW FIRM, a professional law corporation; NATIONWIDE VIN MARKETING, a business entity form unknown; CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF MOTOR VEHICLES, an agency of the State of California; and DOES 1 through 20, inclusive, Defendants. Barrera Merriles, both 43, both of San Diego, and insurance agents Byron Arthur Frisch, 36, of Carlsbad, and. com n. 4 stars. Settled. See reviews, photos, directions, phone numbers and more for Sadr And Barrera Law Office locations in Chula Vista, CA. Compare detailed profiles, including free consultation options, locations, contact information, awards and education. Car Accident Lawyers Serving North Las Vegas, NV (Las Vegas, NV) Helping clients with all of their Motor Vehicle Accidents needs. Call (800) 561-8627 or contact us online to schedule a free consultation. No. Update This CaseThe above table lists lawyers near the attorney office of Kasra Sadr. It is alleged that Sadr conspired to acquire the plaintiffs’ personal and private records from the DMV in order to sue car dealerships via mailings. Feature Your Profile. We have successfully recovered over $400 million for car, truck, motorcycle, uber, lyft, bicycle, pedestrian, and other t. (619) 233-8460. The latest involves 100+ claims based on just one thing: Vehicle License Fees! In fact, we've seen at least two San Diego law firms make this kind of allegation - Hal Rosner (Auto Fraud Legal Center) and Kasra Sadr (The Car Law Firm). There are certain law firms that work together and Kasra Sadr is no exception. Editorial Note: We earn a commission from. THE SADR LAW FIRM, A PROFESSIONAL LAW CORPORATION is a California Stock Corporation - Ca - Professional filed on September 2, 2009. Garland Automobile Accidents Lawyers. com | Website: Not Available. 5 6 reviews. Address: The Sadr Law Firm, APLC, 1455 Frazee Rd Ste 500, San Diego, CA 92108-4350. Represented By. Car Accident Lawyers Serving Memphis, TN (Memphis, TN) Honest, Compassionate & Aggressive Representation. SADR LAW OFFICE, A PROFESSIONAL LAW CORPORATION is a California Stock Corporation - Ca - Professional filed on July 21, 2023. 1455 Frazee Rd San Diego, CA 92108 2222. , ECF No. Kasra Sadr and his Car Law Firm are a legit company targetting used car dealers in the San Diego area for the most part. ’ Opp. dba hawthorne motors express heydari, nima sam other rulings in case {{#if this. Law Office of Craig Gibbs 904-396-4499. You may have suffered physical injuries, emotional distress, and. , Defendants. of The Car Law Firm has been suing California auto dealers for years. In 2006 S & B loaned Kismit Cyriacks a total of $35,000 under two written promissory notes. Disposition. San Diego, CA, 92108. Los Angeles. On August 23, 2022, the California attorney general reached a $1. Lawyers at the firm have represented over 32,000 clients in cases involving car and boating accidents, brain injuries, defective products, drug injuries, environmental injuries, and dog bites. Attorney/Law Firm Details. 313-924-1305 Law Firm Profile Contact us. Download vCard. The company's filing status is listed as Active and its File Number is 3252549. Hilfe. 01-$500. ”) (stating Sadr is the founder of both SLF and CLF). Immigration. C. 101 (First Amended Complaint). Kasra has 2 jobs listed on their profile. document. Marjan Kasra is an EB-5 immigration attorney and the founder of the Law Offices of Marjan Kasra, LLC, an immigration law firm based in Stamford, Conn. . 6400. Car Law Firm, and The Sadr Law Firm used plaintiffs’ information the purpose of sending letters to them to solicit representation for litigation against the sellers of the vehicles that plaintiffs purchased. Specialties: Car Law Firm is an association between independent law firms and attorneys all across California, and focuses solely on dealer fraudulent activities. by anonymous for attorney | Hired Attorney. In 2010, the low point for the al-Qaeda effort in Iraq, car bombings declined to an average of ten a month and multiple-location attacks occurred only two or three times a year. Telephone: (707) 919-5130. Research legal experience, education, professional associations, jurisdictions and contact information on Justia. ---3/23/2017: 011600002139: Consumer: Alaska USA Federal Credit Union: AAA: Dismissed: 1/21/2016: Consumer: Kasra Sadr - Car Law Firm---Byron Berry Esq. 2M JUDGMENT. 350 San Diego, CA 92122. The company's filing status is listed as Active and its File Number is 3252549. Settled. Douglass Jennings, Jr. Wallace Miller. VS KASRA SADR, ESQ. THE K. File a Complaint. The complaint alleges that defendants Kasra Sadr, Car Law Firm, and The Sadr Law Firm used plaintiffs' information the purpose of sending letters to them to solicit representation for litigation against. L. Starting a startup? Join the world's largest startup network for guidance, tools, and fundraising opportunities. According to an indictment, the defendants—La Jolla brokers Byron Frisch and Kristian Giordano, and San Diego attorneys Kasra Sadr and Brenda Barrera— deceived insurance companies in a number. A full service law firm, focusing on a number of legal disciplines critical in today's fast-paced environment. Include similar sounding names. Parker Inc. Claim this listing for free. reviews. IN BUSINESS. 921. service. Asset Protection, Tax Planning, Wills & Trusts, Estate Planning, Probate Law, Estate Law, Corporate Planning, Civil LitigationWe may be able to help you get the money you need to cover the costs of repairs or simply find a different car altogether. POOCHIGIAN, JENNIFER T . Not eligible to practice law in CA Discipline w/actual suspension 12-O-10851: 6/4/2012. what does a car accident attorney do; kasra sadr car law. 678-541-7669 Law Firm Profile Contact us. Schedule your Deal Jacket Review to see how liable your dealership may be & protect yourself from lawsuitsBest General Litigation near Tax Investment Pension Law Center - California Lemon Law Attorneys, Law Offices of William R. Immigration. The Sadr Law Firm is committed to providing the highest quality legal service, tailored to specific needs of each client. Posted by anonymous | October 8, 2020. 76% 17. A St. Our records show it was established in California. Find top rated Car Accident attorneys from the Super Lawyers directory. A. |. York, Deputy 5 Attorney for Plaintiff(s), Carlos Gonzalez 8 SUPERIOR COURT OF THK. 972-349-4496. Scott Westlund KRW Lawyers 210-490-4357 . Pls. It is undisputed that Cyriacks did not repay the principal amounts of the notes. Lawyers: Marianne Denton Alice S. 2:20-cv. Sekumade Law Firm: 10909 Sabo Rd # 115, Houston, TX 77089: Law Offices of Rowett: 5629 FM 1960 # 313, Houston, TX 77069: Law Offices: 3200 Southwest Fwy, Houston, TX 77027: Roberson Law Firm: 2700 Post Oak Blvd 21st Floor, Houston, TX 77056: Center for Advanced Legal Studies: 800 W Sam Houston Pkwy S #100, Houston, TX 77042:. 2:20-cv-1034 MCE AC. Car Accident Lawyers Serving Schaumburg, IL and Cook County, Illinois. Email: info@madisonlawapc. | Madison Law is a full service law firm, focusing on a number of legal disciplines critical in today's fast-paced environment. Tax Free Inheritance Trust. (619) 722-3024 Message. If you have any personal experience of lawyer Sadr Law Firm APLC, who specializes mainly in "Steinger, Iscoe & Greene has been a San Diego personal injury legal practice since 1997. ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED. Operation Imposing Law, also known as Operation Law and Order (Arabic: عملية القانون والنظام, romanized: amaliat al-qaanoon wa an-nazaam), Operation Fardh al-Qanoon (Arabic: فرض القانون) or Baghdad Security Plan (BSP), was a joint Coalition-Iraqi security plan conducted throughout Baghdad. 1455 Frazee Rd Ste 500. | Madison Law is a full service law firm, focusing on a number of legal disciplines critical in today's fast-paced environment. ECF No. A corporate law firm. Sadr is a California-licensed attorney and is associated with two law firms: SLF, of which he is the sole officer and director, and CLF, which is an association of independent law firms that includes SLF. 1 at 2. Irvine, California, United States. Attorney Ms. S. 03/26/2019. ECF No. Law Firm: Sheppard Mullin - Los Angeles Office ;Specialties: Car Law Firm is an association between independent law firms and attorneys all across California, and focuses solely on dealer fraudulent activities. 24, at 2– 3 (“Defs. Depending on which direction you're coming from, follow the directions below: From I-75 Southbound: Take the 16th Street Exit. Arbitrator. com. Sadr Law Firm A P L C, Court Case No. 101 at 2. Kasra Sadr was quite impressive while representing my case. Defendant. 0 stars 1 review. Kasra Sadr, Member Attorney Business, Asset Protection, Tax Planning, Estate Planning, Corporate Planning, Civil Litigation: Phone:(877) 577-7237 Address: 401 W. San Diego car accident lawyers should work on contingency. 650 Larkfield Center Suite B-1,, Santa Rosa, CA, United States, California. Find Reviews, Ratings, Directions, Business Hours, Contact. Author: San Diego,. Law School Regulation; Access to Justice. Hill, SBN 343167 brian@bbr. beauty. Visit Website. In the case of a car accident, it refers to the amount of time you have to file a lawsuit against the person or entity responsible for the accident. Ocean Blvd. Serving Cape Coral, FL ( View address ) 239-308-0173. Dolan Law Firm PC. Appointed 7/7/2016. 101 at 2. Results matter but our clients come first. Car Accident Lawyers at 325 North LaSalle Drive, Suite 300, Chicago, IL 60654. Our Los Angeles lemon law attorneys can level the playing field and get you the respect you deserve. Santa Rosa, CA 95403. Contact. Sadr Law Firm A P L C, Court Case No. Read the story of how the Car Law Firm, specializing in suing dealerships, was hit with a judgment of $1. Visit Website. Andrejka, Erika. Car Law Firm is an association between independent law firms and attorneys all across California, and focuses solely on dealer fraudulent activities. Greater San Diego Area. Fox, and Edmond Tarverdian (collectively, “Plaintiffs”) seek to stop Defendants Kasra Sadr (“Sadr”), the Car Law Firm (“CLF”), the Sadr Law Firm (“SLF”), and Nationwide VIN Marketing. Issues:Aug 22 2013. law 2 Kaleb L. Sadr Law Firm; 610 West Ash Street # 1101; San Diego, CA 92101. McKinley LLP. 17, 2023, at 6:55 p. Thank you all and wish success to all of you. Your Profile? Update Now. Top rated Car Accident lawyer. CLF seeks toParties, docket activity and news coverage of federal case AKKAWI et al v. Car Law Firm. 350 San Diego, CA 92122. Kasra Sadr is Asset Protection attorney from San Diego, CA. “They wanted thousands of dollars to settle the case. , Defendants. California, 11-08-2023. , Ste. com. S MOTION TO. EDT. Warner on 4/4/2011. Find top Columbia, SC Car Accident attorneys near you. This is a review for a general litigation business in San Diego, CA: "A little over 3yrs ago i was contacted by Car Law Firm, informing me i had brought a unsafe framed damage car from a shady dealership. Kasra Sadr has been associated with three companies, according to public records. I’ve been working at this Law Firm for over 4-years. Information not available. Sadr seems to target dealers. Established in 2015. Auto Body Shops Auto Glass Repair Auto Parts Auto Repair Car Detailing Oil Change Roadside Assistance Tire Shops Towing Window Tinting. Represented By. CALL NOW VISIT WEBSITE. | Madison Law is a full service law firm, focusing on a number of legal disciplines critical in today's fast-paced environment. Best Car Accident Lawyers Anaheim, CA Of 2023. Phone: (619) 233-8460. kasra@parsadlaw. Our San Francisco office is in the Mid-Market neighborhood of San Francisco, near the federal and state courthouses in the city. At The McBride Law Firm, we understand that a car accident can be a traumatic experience. Official Blog of Madison Law Attorneys. Qualified Personal Residence Trust. ’ App. Any registered vehicle owner who is contacted by NASC may have a claim under Sutton's surety bond for $50,000. 1455 Frazee Rd . McGee, Gupta evans and Associates PC, Panakos Law, APC, Buscemi Hallett LLP, Jaffe Law Corporation, Car Law FirmThis case was last updated from San Diego County Superior Courts on 03/30/2022 at 19:41:12 (UTC). Not Classified By Court: Kasra Sadr, founder of The Sadr Law Firm, is an active member of the American and San Diego Bar Associations with a background in International Politics and Business and Tax Management, combined with his baccalaureate in Political Science from the University of California, San Diego, and his Doctorate in Jurisprudence from California Western. This means that there are no up-front costs and the attorney only gets paid if they get you paid. Jessica Burgoyne. This case was last updated from San Diego County Superior Courts on 03/30/2022 at 19:41:12 (UTC). Kasra Sadr President: THE SADR LAW FIRM, A PROFESSIONAL LAW CORPORATION: 610 W Ash Ste 1104, San Diego,. Contact. Open 64 Days Type Consumer. , 8605 Santa Monica Blvd, Pmb 39375, West Hollywood, CA 90069-4109. The. San Francisco, CA 94105. Email Kasra Sadr. September 6, 2023 at 2:20 p. Knowledgeable 1. 814 Long Beach, CA 90802 Telephone: (562) 590-5550 Facsimile: (562) 590-8400 Attorneys for Plaintiff JAIME GODINEZ, as representative of the State of. Arash Law is proud to be California's go-to injury law firm led by Arash Khorsandi. We have the necessary expertise, the requisite associations, and the large. , Defendants. SENIOR UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE. Represented By. CALL (212) 500-0905. Richard 915-241-6550 . AAA Case #011600029143, involving Sterling Imports, Ltd. Super Lawyers ®. San Diego, CA. Button, Eric M. Lawyer Kasra Sadr, graduated from University of California San Diego, La Jolla CA, , California Western School of Law, San Diego CA California Western School of Law, Class of 1996, Juris Doctorate, is now employed by The Sadr Law Firm A Professional Law Corporation at 401 W. Find out what works well at The Law Offices of Marjan Kasra, LLC from the people who know best. He targets car buyers with personalized alarming letters informing them that the car they bought from you have incurred in structural or frame damage, even on a "clean" Carfax or Autocheck reports. C. View profile . The Law Office of Richard R. We as of today completed the arbitration hearing and are awaiting the decision. 4 The complaint alleges that defendants Kasra Sadr, Car Law Firm, and The Sadr Law Firm 5 used plaintiffs’ information the purpose of sending letters to them to solicit representation for 6 litigation against the sellers of the vehicles that plaintiffs purchased. Visit law firm profile. This business has 0 complaints. Geller, Michael S. Creating your profile on CaseMine allows you to build your network with fellow lawyers and prospective clients. Average of 1 Customer Reviews. ECF No. C. License Status, Disciplinary and Administrative History. dba Hawthorne Motors Express (Plaintiff) filed suit against Kasra Sadr, Esq, the Sadr Law Firm, and the Car Law Firm, alleging: (1) defamation per se; (2) defamation per quod; (3) trade libel; (4) violation of. The complaint alleges that defendants Kasra Sadr, Car Law Firm, and The Sadr Law Firm used plaintiffs’ information the purpose of send ing letters to them to solicit representation for litigation against the sellers of the vehicles that plaintiffs purchased. rather than a unified organization with a firm internal. Top rated Car Accident lawyer. THE SADR LAW FIRM, A PROFESSIONAL LAW CORPORATION is a California Stock Corporation - Ca - Professional filed on September 2, 2009. Domain Informations. Justice begins with your story and it ends with results. No. Since the secondThe parties have been participating in discovery. Law Declaration - DECLARATION OF KASRA SADR IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT MCLAREN AUTOMOTIVE, INC. Attorney profiles include the biography, education and training, and client. McGee, Buscemi Hallett, Alexander & Associates, Pokala Law, Grace Jasmine Lynn, Turnbow Law Firm, Panakos Law, APC, The CA Law Firm, Gaston and Gaston, APLC, Lynch LLPMadison Law, APC | 76 abonnés sur LinkedIn. Auto Body Shops Auto Glass Repair Auto Parts Auto Repair Car Detailing Oil Change Roadside Assistance Tire Shops Towing Window Tinting. 101 (First Amended Complaint). , ECF No. This law firm is not professional and prey on innocent people promise and under deliver. Whether you were injured in a head-on collision, a rear-end collision, or an intersection accident, a car wreck law firm in Kent can help you get the compensation you deserve. 101 at 2. America's. Hal Rosner Found 7 people in Florida, New York and 4 other states. Lee, Chong Law Group, Robert Sidell Injury Attorney, Hwang Law Group, Craig P. SADR, KASRA. ECF Nos. Yasni Login. More about This Attorney. This case was. Car Accident Lawyers Serving Stockbridge, GA (Duluth, GA) Kuveikis Law, P. net Latra Theriault (SBN: 330474) Itheriault@mahoney-law. The firm handles tort cases and seeks damages from intoxicated and negligent drivers, truckers, and insurance companies. at 5; see Defs. McGee, Pokala Law, Buscemi Hallett, Panakos Law, APC, Car Law Firm, Grace Jasmine Lynn, Gupta Evans and Ayres, The CA Law Firm, Turnbow Law FirmCreating your profile on CaseMine allows you to build your network with fellow lawyers and prospective clients. A California Corporation P & P Motors in the jurisdiction of Los Angeles County, CA. A. No. No. Since the secondWhy Choose Kasra Sadr Car Law Firm. A statute of limitations is a law that sets a specific deadline for individuals to file a lawsuit in civil or criminal court. The Sadr Law Firm, APLC 1455 Frazee Rd Ste 500, San Diego, CA, 92108-4350 Phone:(619) 233-8460 City: San Diego, State: California Zip:92108-4350 Bio Kasra Sadr is an attorney at The Sadr Law Firm, APLC in San Diego, California. Senate Democrats Kill Effort to Repeal Electric Car Rule. Pls. , Defendants.